A smooth tar finish comes from preparing the surface well, applying a thin even coat, wiping away excess, and avoiding thick ridges, dust, and cold application conditions.
Tar naturally wants to show the texture beneath it. On rough sawn wood, rope, or canvas it will not become a smooth furniture finish. A smoother result begins before application, with dry timber that has been sanded or planed to the desired surface and cleaned of dust.
Use a thin coat and spread it evenly with a brush or cloth. Work along the grain and brush out ridges before they settle. If the tar is too cold and thick, it may drag rather than flow. A product that can be warmed gently by room temperature or thinned according to its instructions will usually behave better than a stiff mass forced onto the wood.
A smooth tar finish is still a tar finish. It may remain more satin, smoky, and uneven than varnish or paint. The aim is controlled darkening and a clean surface, not a plastic-looking coating. If the project needs a polished indoor result, tar may not be the right finish.